If I could join the Reality TV craze with my own show, I would propose, Extreme Communication Makeovers of Reality TV Stars. My role would be to help these new celebrities by giving them the tools to manage their outbursts, emotions and conflicts in ways that would elevate their public image, status and professionalism.
Here are some samples of how I would coach some of our favorite stars:
Bethenny Frankel: ”I’m high-maintenance and that’s just me!” She defended to her husband in last week’s Bethenny Ever After, after arguing how much time to spend with his parents. She really demands that people accept her with all of her flaws (probably because she’s working so hard to accept herself). To her credit, she is bravely exposing her own therapy and process to us, but, her communication style has a bullying effect that gives others two choices: appease her or walk. Right now her husband is all about giving her love and being sympathetic, but my fear for her is that unless she learns how to manage her emotional intensity and stop needing to push people to the brink in proving their acceptance of her, she will lose what’s dearest to her.
Me: Bethenny, how’s this: Jason, thank you for hearing my point of view. I value your feelings and know we’ll figure out a solution that supports our little family. Hang in there with me while I work this out in my mind and let’s keep talking!
Teresa Guidice: “Prostitution whore!” she yelled, as she flung a table out of sheer frustration at Danielle Staub, showing us what a Real Housewife of New Jersey‘s rage can look like.
Me: “Teresa, try this: ‘Danielle, I’m sorry you’ve had such difficulty in your life and I simply cannot become involved in this turmoil. Can we all just have a nice lunch now?’”
Patti Stanger: “You’re out of my club, now get out!” she, of Millionnaire Matchmaker fame, screamed, to a rich but emotionally underdeveloped client (who had rejected her advice about dating).
Me: “Patti, how about, ‘The only way I’ll be able to help you find love in the future is if you take my advice. What change are you willing to commit to for next time? ‘”
Tabatha Coffey: “You’re a disaster as a salon manager. I’m taking over!” the star of Tabatha’s Salon Takeover sneered, with disgust, as she took the keys from an emasculated hair salon owner.
Me: “Hey Tabatha, perhaps this, ‘There’s a lot to be done here and I’m so glad you sought my help. I’m going to teach you how to thrive. Now let’s get started.’”
Not such entertaining dialog, you might say? You are correct! It’s no fun to see people stay in control, at least not when we’re watching them on TV. I admit, I’m addicted to these over-the-top reactions. But why? Because it is fascinating to me that successful adults with money, family and friends and education (okay, so maybe all of those mentioned are not what you’d call educated) — people with ‘everything’ don’t have the tools to communicate in ways that yield more positive results when conflict arises.
This makes for great TV, admittedly. But being a communications coach who helps people make positive impact with others, I can’t help but evaluate these outbursts and wonder how I might be able to help these women. Off camera, these ways of being can be quite destructive. Reacting as threatened, offended, defensive and vituperative shows the need to be right and to prove the other person wrong. This is not the kind of detached, mature management of a situation by a self-aware, confident adult.
Think about it. If you watched The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills, you know all about the chain reaction of Kyle and Camille’s downfall with one another. Background is that Camille heard that Kyle said something to the effect of, “Why would anyone want to invite Camille without Kelsey (I think to some Hawaiian retreat)?” Camille calls Kyle out on it, Kyle denies. They go back and forth until Kyle starts spewing hateful things at Camille. Camille declares herself a victim of sheer jealousy. In an act of showing her true character, she fires Kyle’s husband as the realtor for the Grammers’ multi-million dollar real-estate investments. This is to get back at Kyle. Kyle backs off and apologizes for any misunderstanding with Camille to save her husband’s business. Suddenly, she didn’t have to be right, she just had to make things right. But it was too late. As the momentum of the downfall continued, Camille contrived yet more opportunity to protect herself from Kyle — a dinner party starring psychic, Allison DuBois, who smokes electronic cigarettes and spews venim. She actually told Kyle that she will never find fulfillment with her husband. “KNOW THAT,” she sneered.
What does that kind of hostility buy? Infamy? What person would feel safe going to Allison DuBois for a reading after seeing her behave this way?
Kyle’s far from innocuous when it comes to controlling her mouth, as we know, having watched the devastating collapse of her relationship with her sister Kim, in the last episode. There’s obviously a lot of pain and trauma in that family and this is not something I will venture to touch upon other than to say I wish them healing. But the point remains: that a communication makeover is in dire need to be part of repairing the damage.
Fundamentally, when conflict arises, the key thing that puts a salve on the wound is to give the other person the latitude to feel what they feel; to have experienced what they have lived. In order to create any space in which to be heard, we must first give space to the other…and respect what we hear.
As an example, if Patti Stanger is disappointed with a client’s behavior on the date, instead of blowing up and saying things like, “I TOLD YOU TO LET THE GUY PLAN THE DATE!” or “YOU’RE LIVING IN A FANTASY LAND AND WILL NEVER FIND LOVE!” — reactions that only give rise to defensiveness, she might say to herself, “I know I’m the expert and I don’t have to defend it, I’m here to help this person.” And with compassion, calmly describe the benefits to her clients for changing their behavior for next time (and in doing so, creating a next time). Instead, Patti Stanger comes across to me as someone who is so hot-headed that even if she knows exactly how to help people find love, that she’s not professional enough to handle difficult clients. What’s on the line for her is a lost opportunity to prove she can connect people; a demand that TV must fuel. However, she demands so much respect that there’s no compromise. We can’t demand respect, we have to model what is respectful about us. Patti knows that her lonely millionaires have psychological barriers about intimacy. Why not be more compassionate as they stumble?
Hair salons have a gift in Tabatha Coffey. Tabatha IS always right. I love how she puts people’s businesses on track for success. But look at how long it usually takes people to get past the bitchiness, the brashness, the harshness? She earns respect every time, but in such a hard way that people bristle when they see her. Maybe this is what Tabatha wants; it is certainly not hurting her TV career. But I know there is a better way and I know that experts never have to cause such upsetment, loathing and fear in order to be effective. People don’t have to be humiliated when they are searching for help, but frequently they allow themselves to be and the expert should be skilled in helping them avoid feeling humiliated instead of sparking it.
I say this all with compassion for these women, by the way; being a Reality TV Star must be a complicated and risky situation and I certainly admire their openness about who they are. If I were to actually get my own show I’m sure I would want to turn to many of these people for insight and pointers.
One of the key things I would envision in doing an Extreme Communication Makeover of Reality TV Stars show would be to teach people how to give recognition when it is deserved. And so, as a first act, I commend you, Andy Cohen, Reality TV Star and Bravo programming genius, in making these women feel loved and respected for who they are by the way you manage your conversations with them. In the light-hearted and good-natured manner in which you help them laugh at themselves. In the way you create a safe environment on, Watch What Happens L!ve. You are masterful as a mediator and in your ability to make people feel good about themselves.
Happy Viewing!
Jackie
Copyright, Jackie Kellso and PointMaker Communications, 2011-2012. Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Jackie Kellso and PointMaker Communications with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.